Jean-Baptiste Carpeaux
Pourquoi Naître Esclave? (Why Should I be Born a Slave?)

CultureFrench
Titles
  • Pourquoi Naître Esclave? (Why Should I be Born a Slave?)
Datec. 1873–1874, modeled 1867
MediumBronze
Dimensions25 1/4 × 20 × 14 in. (64.1 × 50.8 × 35.6 cm)
Credit LineMuseum purchase funded by the Brown Foundations Accessions Endowment
Object number2024.67
Current Location
The Audrey Jones Beck Building
220 McNair Gallery
Exposé

Explore Further

Object Type
Description

The sculpture was modeled in 1867 and this bronze was made very soon after. The cast is larger than the other known casts and therefore is likely the first of the many bronze versions.


Provenance[Sotheby’s, London, May 12,1995, lot 74]; Private collection, London, 1995–2024; [Stuart Lochhead Ltd., London]; purchased by MFAH, 2024.

Exhibition HistoryUnknown
Inscriptions, Signatures and Marks
Hand-chased inscription on the front of the base: POURQUOI NAITRE ESCLAVE
[none]
Stamped above the inscription on the front of the base: Proprieté Carpeaux / Eagle stamp
Catalogue raisonnéPoletti, Michel and Alain Richarme, Jean-Baptiste Carpeaux, sculpteur. Catalogue raisonné de l’œuvre édité. Paris : L’Editions de l’Amateur, 2003, 141-2, BU38, BU39.

Cataloguing data may change with further research.

If you have questions about this work of art or the MFAH Online Collection please contact us.

Alexandre Dumas Fils
Jean-Baptiste Carpeaux
1873
Bronze
73.171
Bust of the Imperial Prince
Jean-Baptiste Carpeaux
1865
Plaster
2013.245
Battle of the Roman Bulls
Jean-Baptiste Clésinger
c. 1862
Bronze
2000.593
Portrait of a Young Boy
Jean-Baptiste Lantscroon
1690–1694
Oil on canvas
77.335
Orpheus Leading Eurydice from the Underworld
Jean-Baptiste-Camille Corot
1861
Oil on canvas
87.190
The Departure of the Boatman
Jean-Baptiste-Camille Corot
1870–1872
Oil on canvas
78.147
Portrait of a Young Woman
Jean-Baptiste Greuze
1790–1805
Oil on panel
2012.283
A Pastoral Concert
Jean-Baptiste Pater
c. 1725
Oil on panel
44.544
Head of Diana
Jean-Alexandre-Joseph Falguière
after 1882
Bronze
94.449
The Expiring Eagle of Waterloo
Jean-Léon Gérôme
c. 1902
Gilt bronze mounted on worked granite
2005.1066
Venus Marina
1650–1700
Bronze
69.3
Seal
1638?
Bronze
37.57